A climate adaptation solution can be technically sound and still be impossible to finance. Consider solutions as varied as drought-tolerant seeds, solar irrigation pumps, and livestock health sensors. When these solutions struggle to scale, the usual response is to call for more capital, either through a credit line, a guarantee, or a blended finance facility.
While the need for more capital for adaptation is real, more of it alone will not finance these solutions. A more fundamental question we should ask is: Is the inability to attract finance really a bankability problem or a product design problem?
Our recent work across Asia and Africa points to a more nuanced answer. In India, for instance, we examined 28 climate-affected problem areas across eight subsectors: farming, dairy, poultry, goat rearing, fisheries, forestry, and rural and urban waste. We focused on the poorest 30% of producers, who are the most exposed to climate shocks.
In most cases, the solutions were already available. The problem was that people were not using them. Without adoption, lenders had little revenue or evidence of repayment to finance. Adoption was low because the products had not been designed around the realities of the people they were meant to serve.
That distinction changes how we should think about adaptation finance. The lack of finance is a symptom, while the underlying problem is often the product. A lender will struggle to finance a product whose returns depend on performance that has never been shown in the borrower’s conditions. When a product fits its users, performs in their real-world conditions, and generates evidence of that performance, lenders have something they can assess. That makes financing far easier.
Dairy in India shows the problem clearly
Take the case of dairy in India, where more than 80 million rural households keep dairy animals and 95% of producers have five or fewer. For these smallholders, the economics of dairy can hinge on events that are easy to miss. Their income depends on two things: Animals that stay healthy and animals that become pregnant on time. A cow or buffalo can conceive only during a short window, known as heat, which comes about every three weeks and often passes overnight. Each missed window delays pregnancy by three weeks and costs the farmer INR 4,000 to 6,000 (about USD 40 to 65) in lost milk and extra feed.
Health problems create another hidden cost. Mastitis, an udder infection, can reduce milk yields long before visible symptoms appear. With one veterinarian for every 4,600 animals, and hotter weather making both problems worse, the costs are high. Today, dairy cattle diseases alone cost India more than USD 12 billion a year.
This is where wearable technology appears promising. Wearable sensors, one such adaptation solution, track movement, rumination, and temperature, and alert the farmer when an animal comes into heat or begins to fall ill. On large farms abroad, they identify heat more than 90% of the time and flag many illnesses before symptoms appear. Indian companies, such as Stellapps and Prompt Equipments, now offer versions for local farms, with some collars priced at around INR 6,500 (about USD 70). Yet these devices reach only a small share of India’s 300 million cattle and buffaloes, and their accuracy in Indian conditions has yet to be independently tested at scale. As experts reiterated in our conversations, “Wearable technologies need to be adapted to India’s tied animal systems.”
Why the technology has not reached smallholders
MSC has spent more than 25 years helping service providers design products for low- and middle-income customers. Our Market Insights for Innovation and Design (Mi4iD) approach rests on a simple idea. Customers experience a product through eight dimensions, known as the 8Ps: Product, price, place, people, process, physical evidence, positioning, and promotion. A weakness in any one can stop adoption. Applied to dairy wearables, the 8Ps show where current products fall short for smallholders and what a better fit would require (Figure 1).

Figure 1: An 8Ps diagnosis of dairy wearables for Indian smallholders, with proposed design targets, MSC analysis
Each gap is a different reason for the same result. The technology does not reach the farmers who need it most, and lenders have no evidence on which to finance it. This is not just a dairy problem. We see the same gap between the solutions on offer and what vulnerable people need in our recent climate finance work in Asia, across Bangladesh, Bhutan, Cambodia, Fiji, Lao PDR and Nepal, and in Africa, across Ethiopia, Kenya, Mozambique, Nigeria, Rwanda and Tanzania.
Solar irrigation in Mozambique illustrates this. Solar pumps can keep crops watered through drier seasons, and the technology is proven. Yet most pumps in use draw from deep boreholes, which few smallholders can afford, and theft of panels is a major risk. A smallholder system costs around EUR 1,000 (about USD 1,100), well beyond what most farmers can pay upfront. The challenges continue even after purchase. When a pump breaks down, spare parts must be ordered from the supplier, and downtime averages nine days, long enough to lose a harvest.
A smallholder-ready system would therefore need to look different. It would be portable, work with the water sources farmers have, and be sold on seasonal or pay-as-you-go terms with local servicing. Once again, the technology is not the missing piece. What is missing is a design built around the people who need it.
What can climate adaptation learn from financial inclusion?
Financial services for low-income customers faced the same problem two decades ago. Products designed for wealthier customers were offered with minor changes, and many went unused. The World Bank’s 2014 Global Findex found that 43% of Indian account holders had made no deposit or withdrawal in the past year. Progress came when providers became market-led. Instead of asking how to sell an existing product to low-income customers, they began by understanding how those customers manage their money. They then tested and refined products across all 8Ps before scaling them.
Kenya’s Equity Bank shows what this looks like in practice. Its first pilot of Biashara Imara, a cash-flow-based loan for small businesses without collateral, failed in 2003. The failure, however, proved useful. Refined with MSC through client feedback, from loan sizes and terms to staff training and incentives, the relaunched product reached more than 25,000 outstanding loans worth USD 8 million within a year. Over two decades of such work with MSC, Equity’s customer base grew from 109,000 to more than 12 million. The same approach has since driven innovations in the delivery of digital financial services through agents.
The lesson for all stakeholders in the market is simple: Solutions are adopted and scaled up when they fit the people who use them. Many adaptation solutions are not being adopted because they fall short on one or more of the 8Ps. That creates a financing problem downstream. Getting the design right needs a mechanism that can absorb the early costs and risks of testing, refining, and validating products in real market conditions, while generating evidence on what works and what can scale.
Challenge funds are one such mechanism. By defining a problem precisely, setting measurable targets for performance and cost, and rewarding the solutions that meet them, they pull innovators toward what users need and generate the evidence that lenders and investors look for. In India, the^delta prize is applying this approach to climate and livelihoods, and MSC has been supporting the design of its challenges, drawing on our research in Climate Big Bets 2047.
Lenders, too, have a role to play once solutions are ready. They can make their own products more responsive through approaches such as MSC’s repurpose, rejig and reinvent framework. With it, lenders can steer existing loans toward adaptation, adjust terms, such as matching repayments to the seasons, and build new products where needed. MSC has applied it with four microfinance institutions in India to finance climate-smart agriculture.
For adaptation finance to reach the people most exposed to climate shocks, the order matters. If we start by understanding users, designing around their realities, and testing whether a solution performs in those conditions, we turn a promising solution into one that customers adopt, lenders can assess, and investors can scale.
